7gen Bloc

Too Much Stuff

Set Font Size:
A | A | A
Article Tools
Print  Email Share This
del.icio.us del.icio.us Digg This! digg reddit reddit facebook facebook newsvine newsvine
By Inspired Protagonist - June 20, 2008

Stuff for Sale HereWe simply buy too much stuff. I have more t-shirts in my closet than I could wear in several lifetimes. Yet someone always wants to give me another one. I have an iPhone, but the newest upgrade looks almost irresistible. In fact, so does the MacBook Air. Shoes, cars, cameras, and clothes almost never wear out before we replace them. We are painfully addicted to buying new stuff. And with each new purchase we consume more non-renewable resources, pollute the planet, and create lots of garbage.

How did this all get started?

Orion magazine’s excellent article by Jeffrey Kaplan, titled, “The Gospel of Consumption,” sheds some essential light on the problem’s history. In the late 1920s, after the war, America had excess manufacturing capacity. So we began to invent needs rather than fulfill them. Kaplan writes:

"In a 1927 interview with the magazine Nation’s Business, Secretary of Labor James J. Davis provided some numbers to illustrate a problem that the New York Times called “need saturation.” Davis noted that 'the textile mills of this country can produce all the cloth needed in six months’ operation each year' and that 14 percent of the American shoe factories could produce a year’s supply of footwear. The magazine went on to suggest, 'It may be that the world’s needs ultimately will be produced by three days’ work a week.'

"President Herbert Hoover’s 1929 Committee on Recent Economic Changes observed in glowing terms the results: “By advertising and other promotional devices...a measurable pull on production has been created which releases capital otherwise tied up.” They celebrated the conceptual breakthrough: “Economically we have a boundless field before us; that there are new wants which will make way endlessly for newer wants, as fast as they are satisfied.”

"Our modern predicament is a case in point. By 2005 per capita household spending (in inflation-adjusted dollars) was twelve times what it had been in 1929, while per capita spending for durable goods — the big stuff such as cars and appliances — was thirty-two times higher. And according to reports by the Federal Reserve Bank in 2004 and 2005, over 40 percent of American families spend more than they earn. The average household carries $18,654 in debt, not including home-mortgage debt, and the ratio of household debt to income is at record levels, having roughly doubled over the last two decades. We are quite literally working ourselves into a frenzy just so we can consume all that our machines can produce."

We know our unsustainable rate of consumption impoverishes the planet; it also does the same to our souls. All the “stuff” we lust after does not tend to make us happier.

"We have impoverished our human communities with a form of materialism that leaves us in relative isolation from family, friends, and neighbors. We simply don’t have time for them. Unlike our great-grandparents who passed the time, we spend it. An outside observer might conclude that we are in the grip of some strange curse, like a modern-day King Midas whose touch turns everything into a product built around a microchip."

Kaplan reminds us that time is also a non-renewable resource. Perhaps, by conserving time, we’d have time enough to realize what makes us truly happy.

To read the full story in Orion magazine, click here.

photo: Derek Baird

Comments
Well said,
Posted by 1972jbird | Sun, Jun. 22, 2008

Being overpopulated and consuming more in a year than someone should probably in a lifetime we are in over our heads, I think that is why more and more are trying to get out and off grid. We are not going to pay for all of this are children and grandkids are. I think about that when I see something I want but don't need.

Timely comments
Posted by annemj | Wed, Jun. 25, 2008

The recently late & forever great George Carlin addressed this very topic! He pointed out:

"That's all your house is — it's a place to keep your stuff while you go out and get more stuff. Now sometimes — sometimes you gotta move. You gotta get a bigger house. Why? Too much stuff. You've gotta move all your stuff, and maybe put some of your stuff in storage. Imagine that — there's a whole industry based on keeping an eye on your stuff."

And, whole, entire industries based on dealing with our stuff after we throw it away.....

Deeper issue?
Posted by mississippiGirl | Wed, Jun. 25, 2008

I don't want to fall into the trap of blaming the advertising industry for what amounts to MY lack of self-control. We are all too eager to point the finger of blame to lessen our own guilty feelings about issues like this. So I ask myself, what am I doing to help myself learn that my worth does not lie in what I have, that my happiness does not rely on getting everything that I want, and what am I doing to teach my children these same things? Yes, it started with somebody trying to sell something to someone who didn't need it, but the deeper issue is, they did it by appealing to someone's sense of self-worth and claiming happiness would come from that item. And since we all want to feel like we are worth something and we all want to be happy, we fell for it hook, line, and sinker, and continue to still today.

The Story of Stuff
Posted by cshafer08 | Wed, Jun. 25, 2008

Just yesterday I watched a video on line about this! The website is www.storyofstuff.com It is an awesome video for kids and adults alike to watch! As I was watching it I thought of my dad's cell phone he's had for about 5 years that he won't upgrade on because it WORKS! THANKS DAD!

And to add to Carlin's observation...
Posted by mjg9129 | Wed, Jun. 25, 2008

I can only shake my head when driving by those storage centers. And I hear that many of these facilities have waiting lists... ugh! The wrapper on a bar of Liggett's bar shampoo has the following Old New England "Saw" - we could all benefit from it's wisdom:
"Use it up, wear it out, make it do, or do without."

Voluntary Simplicity
Posted by val1427 | Wed, Jun. 25, 2008

Last year, my husband and I took a Voluntary Simplicity course, using the book "Simpler Living, Compassionate Life" with excerpts from various authors. It's about getting back to our roots to find true joy and purpose in life. I highly recommend the class. If you can't find one in your area - start one like my frineds did. It is making a huge impact in our little community.

Simple Living is my style
Posted by windy1 | Wed, Jun. 25, 2008

I too have been using the principles of Voluntary Simplicity but I got it from the books Your Money or Your Life (Dominguez and Robin) and the Circle of Simplicity. D. Elgin has the classic book Voluntary Simplicity. They are all available on the web site for Simple Living and Amazon. I got all my books from the public library, so as not to consume more. They are good resource books, so after reading one may want to find them in a second hand bookstore or used. These have been some of my favorite books since I retired and stopped buying! This has been 12 years ago this month and I am still following their principles of Financial Independence. Now many people are in the throws of change which have been coming for a few decades. It really is hard to change these things so quickly. Cheers to all who are trying to downsize.

The Story of Stuff
Posted by katefitzgerald | Wed, Jun. 25, 2008

For a very accessible, yet very complete story of how we -- and all our stuff -- got here, and what the future will or could hold for us, check out www.storyofstuff.com.

This is a 20 min short film that lays everything out in easy to understand concepts and I would recommend it for virtually anyone over 5 years old. The combination of live action with animation allows for complex processes to be well-explained AND compelling. And even if you think you know what you need to know, there is more to learn here!

Too much stuff
Posted by organic wench | Wed, Jun. 25, 2008

I only replace "stuff" when it no longer functions, has holes, or can't be repaired. I still have fleece pullovers that I bought in 1990 that I wear when the weather turns cold. I use my old holey t-shirts to wear when I clean house or do yard work and some of them are at least 20 years old. When I do have to replace something I replace it with a "green alternative," i.e. organic bath towels, organic cotton or bamboo t-shirts, bamboo furniture, CFL bulbs etc. Every little bit helps.

"working... so we can consume all ..." Wrong!
Posted by newexample | Sun, Jun. 29, 2008

As a 26-year-old, with a bit of debt, I didn't used to work (while in college) and I consumed everything. 5 years ago consumer credit was given out in high limits to myself and my friends.

Now, because of a lack of consumer education, I work to reduce the debt I irresponsibly accrued. The reason I think people work so much today is not to chase the next hot product. It's to correct their past mistakes, made because of ill-informed decisions. Another example I would offer to this example is the foreclosure crisis. People bought into mortgage deals because they weren't properly educated on the ramifications that could occur. It isn't irrational consumerism to buy a home and if I didn't have the credit in college I wouldn't have worked more hours to find the money to buy the expensive electronic equipment to make due.

Funny that I read this
Posted by jenno | Wed, Aug. 13, 2008

Funny that I read this today, my husband just challenged us to limiting our possessions to 100 items each. It may take me a little bit of time to realize what I can do WITHOUT, but I am determined to meet the goal!

Dear Jenno,
Posted by Inspired Protagonist | Wed, Aug. 13, 2008

Please check in from time to time and let us know how you are doing!
--The Inspired Protagonist